Home Improvement Contractor License #0644307
Slavin Logo

Pros and Cons of Full  Replacement vs. Roofing Over Old Shingles

When it comes to replacing a roof, homeowners are often faced with a crucial decision: whether to tear off the old roof entirely or simply roof over it with new shingles. Each approach has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, which should be carefully considered before making a decision. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of both methods to help homeowners make an informed choice.

Roof Tear-Off and Replacement

One of the significant advantages of tearing off the old roof is the opportunity it provides to inspect the roof deck thoroughly. This allows for the identification and remediation of any underlying issues such as rot, water damage, or structural problems. Addressing these issues upfront can prevent future problems and ensure the longevity of the new roof.

Removing the old roof and starting afresh allows homeowners to choose from a wide range of roofing materials and colors, enabling them to achieve the desired aesthetic for their home. This can significantly enhance the curb appeal and overall appearance of the property.

A completely new roof installed after a tear-off typically has a longer lifespan compared to roofing over existing shingles. With proper maintenance, a new roof can last for several decades, providing homeowners with peace of mind and potentially increasing the resale value of their home.

However, there are some cons you should know about.

Roof tear-off and replacement tend to be more expensive than roofing over existing shingles due to the additional labor and disposal costs involved. Homeowners should budget accordingly and consider whether the benefits outweigh the higher upfront investment.

Furthermore, tear-off and replacement projects generally take longer to complete compared to roofing over existing shingles. This can disrupt daily life and may require homeowners to temporarily relocate during the construction process, adding to the inconvenience.

Lastly, removing the old roof generates a significant amount of waste, which must be disposed of properly. While some materials can be recycled, others may end up in landfills, contributing to environmental concerns. Homeowners concerned about sustainability should weigh this factor carefully.

Roofing Over Old Shingles

Roofing over existing shingles is typically more cost-effective than tear-off and replacement since it requires less labor and disposal of materials. This can be especially beneficial for homeowners on a tight budget or those looking to save money on home improvement projects.

Roofing over old shingles generally requires less time to complete compared to tear-off and replacement, minimizing disruption to daily routines. This can be advantageous for homeowners who need to quickly restore their roof's functionality without lengthy construction delays.

Since the existing shingles remain in place during the installation process, roofing over old shingles tends to cause less disruption to the home's interior and exterior. Homeowners can continue to occupy the property comfortably while the work is being done.

Again, there are some cons to know about.

Roofing over existing shingles does not allow for a thorough inspection of the roof deck, which means that any underlying issues may go unnoticed and unaddressed. This could potentially lead to more significant problems down the line, resulting in costly repairs or premature roof failure.

Installing new shingles over old ones may shorten the lifespan of the new roof compared to a complete tear-off and replacement. The added weight and heat retention from the underlying layer can accelerate deterioration, leading to the need for more frequent repairs or replacement.

Finally, roofing over old shingles limits the choice of materials and colors available, as the existing shingles may affect the appearance of the new roof. This could compromise the homeowner's ability to achieve their desired aesthetic for the property.

If you need top-notch residential roofing, you can always count on us at Slavin Home Improvement. We're a team dedicated to delivering only the best and most reliable roofing service in South Windsor, CT. Call us today or visit our website to get started!



145 New London Turnpike Suite 217, Glastonbury, CT 06033, United States




Mon-Fri 7AM – 5PM
© All Rights Reserved 2023 Slavin Home Improvement
Privacy Policy